WHY ECONOMIC POWER DOES NOT BECOME SOFT POWER: THE CASE OF THE CENTRAL ASIAN STATES

Authors

  • Zakhro Jumanova University of World Economy and Diplomacy image/svg+xml Author

Keywords:

soft power; economic influence; China; Central Asia; Belt and Road Initiative; public opinion

Abstract

China has become the dominant economic actor in Central Asia, yet its standing in regional public opinion has not risen in step with its economic weight, and in several states it has declined. This article asks why economic dominance has failed to translate into soft power. It argues that the conversion fails for a structural reason: China's instruments of influence are overwhelmingly state-directed and operate at the elite level, while attraction is generated in the society-level realm of perception, identity, and everyday experience that Beijing does not control. Drawing on trade and debt statistics, Central Asia Barometer survey data across the five states, and a comparison of China's cultural and educational instruments, the article shows that favourable opinion fell sharply across the region during the very years in which economic ties deepened, and that the one type of instrument that does improve attitudes — vocational training delivering tangible local benefit — is precisely the one that bypasses the elite channel and reaches ordinary citizens. The case of Central Asia therefore confirms a more general proposition: economic power and soft power are distinct resources, and the first does not automatically produce the second. The finding has implications both for China's regional strategy and for the theory of influence.

References

1.Astana Times. (2025, January 24). Kazakhstan ranks first among China's Central Asian trade partners in 2024. https://astanatimes.com/2025/01/kazakhstan-ranks-first-among-chinas-central-asian-trade-partners-in-2024/

2.Bloomsbury Intelligence and Security Institute. (2024). Could Uzbekistan's growing debt to China push Tashkent to search for alternative partners? https://bisi.org.uk/reports/could-uzbekistans-growing-debt-to-china-push-tashkent-to-search-for-alternative-partners

3.Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. (2025). Chinese lending adapts to Central Asia's realities. https://carnegieendowment.org/posts/2024/09/china-investment-central-asia-debt

4.Caspian Policy Center. (2024). In much of Central Asia, perception of China declines. https://www.caspianpolicy.org/research/central-asia/in-much-of-central-asia-perception-of-china-declines

5.Caspian Post. (2025). China–Central Asia trade volume grows 2.8 times. https://caspianpost.com/central-asia/china-central-asia-trade-volume-grows-2-8-times

6.Central Asia Barometer. (2024). Beyond the Silk Road: Navigating the complexities of Central Asia's public opinion of China. Central Asia Barometer.

7.Central Asia-Caucasus Analyst. (2024). China's debt-trap diplomacy in Central Asia. https://www.cacianalyst.org/publications/analytical-articles/item/13823-chinas-debt-trap-diplomacy-in-central-asia.html

8.China-Global South Project. (2025). The perception problem: Why Central Asians remain skeptical of Chinese investment. https://chinaglobalsouth.com/analysis/anti-china-sentiment-central-asia-debt-land-perceptions/

9.Chinascope. (2025). Luban Workshop: The CCP's new global expansion tool after the Confucius Institute. https://chinascope.org/archives/39096

10.Eurasianet. (2020). Poll shows Uzbeks, like neighbors, growing leery of Chinese investments. https://eurasianet.org/poll-shows-uzbeks-like-neighbors-growing-leery-of-chinese-investments

11.Eurasianet. (2022). China expands vocational training centers to Central Asia. https://eurasianet.org/china-expands-vocational-training-centers-to-central-asia

12.Laruelle, M., & Peyrouse, S. (2012). The Chinese question in Central Asia: Domestic order, social change, and the Chinese factor. Hurst.

13.Nationalities Papers. (2023). Academic diplomacy: The educational aspects of Chinese and Russian soft power in Tajikistan. Cambridge University Press.

14.Nye, J. S. (2004). Soft power: The means to success in world politics. PublicAffairs.

15.Orda. (2025). China's trade with Central Asia hits $94.8 billion in 2024. https://en.orda.kz/chinas-trade-with-central-asia-hits-948-billion-in-2024-4874/

16.Railway Supply. (2025). Financing of the China–Kyrgyzstan–Uzbekistan railway. https://www.railway.supply/financing-of-the-china-kyrgyzstan-uzbekistan-railway-model/

17.The Diplomat. (2026). Tajikistan's external debt grows in complexity. https://thediplomat.com/2026/01/tajikistans-external-debt-grows-in-complexity/

18.Times of Central Asia. (2026). Central Asia trade with China tops record $100 billion in 2025. https://timesca.com/central-asia-trade-with-china-tops-record-100-billion-in-2025/

19.Washington Post. (2023). China's Luban Workshops train workers as way to grow global influence. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/interactive/2023/china-luban-workshops-global-influence/

20.Wendt, A. (1999). Social theory of international politics. Cambridge University Press.

Downloads

Published

2026-06-09