THE LEGAL FOUNDATIONS OF THE LEGITIMACY OF ARBITRATOR SELECTION

Authors

  • Nazarova Jasmina Ilkhom qizi Master’s student in International Business and Commercial Law at the University of Liverpool, UK. Author

Keywords:

International Commercial Arbitration; Arbitrator Selection; Legitimacy of Arbitral Tribunals; Party Autonomy; Independence and Impartiality; Procedural Fairness; Transparency; Information Asymmetry; Repeat Appointments; Professional Networks.

Abstract

his article examines the legal foundations of legitimacy in arbitrator selection within international commercial arbitration, focusing on the relationship between party autonomy, procedural fairness, independence, impartiality, and transparency. Drawing primarily on the Arbitration Act 1996, as amended by the Arbitration Act 2025, the UNCITRAL Model Law, and leading institutional arbitration rules, the study analyses the legal principles governing the constitution of arbitral tribunals. Particular attention is given to the distinction between formal procedural rights and the practical ability of parties to make informed decisions when selecting arbitrators. The article explores how information asymmetry, professional networks, reputation, and repeat appointments influence candidate assessment and accessibility. It argues that although existing legal frameworks provide essential safeguards for legitimate tribunal constitution, they do not necessarily ensure equal access to reliable information about prospective arbitrators. The findings suggest that the legitimacy of arbitrator selection depends not only on compliance with applicable legal requirements but also on the meaningful exercise of party autonomy within a sufficiently transparent and impartial procedure. The article concludes that improving access to reliable candidate information may strengthen the practical effectiveness of arbitrator selection without undermining established legal principles or the value of professional expertise.

References

Legislation and International Legal Instruments

1.Arbitration Act 1996 (UK).

2.Arbitration Act 2025 (UK).

3.UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (1985), with amendments as adopted in 2006.

4.Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York Convention), adopted 10 June 1958, entered into force 7 June 1959, 330 UNTS 3.

Institutional Rules and Guidelines

5.International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), ICC Arbitration Rules (2021).

6.London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA), LCIA Arbitration Rules (2020).

7.International Bar Association (IBA), IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest in International Arbitration (2024).

8.Books and Book Chapters

9.Bantekas I and others, UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: A Commentary (Cambridge University Press 2020).

10.Gómez-Acebo A, Party-Appointed Arbitrators in International Commercial Arbitration (Kluwer Law International 2016).

11.Luttrell SR, Bias Challenges in International Commercial Arbitration: The Need for a ‘Real Danger’ Test (Kluwer Law International 2008).

12.Mangan M, Reed L and Choong J, A Guide to the SIAC Arbitration Rules (Oxford University Press 2018).

13.Moses ML, The Principles and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration (4th edn, Cambridge University Press 2024).

14.Journal Articles and Academic Publications

15.Bishop D and Reed L, ‘Practical Guidelines for Interviewing, Selecting and Challenging Party-Appointed Arbitrators in International Commercial Arbitration’ (1998) 14(4) Arbitration International 395.

16.Czaika M and Toma S, ‘International Academic Mobility across Space and Time: The Case of Indian Academics’ (2017) 23(8) Population, Space and Place e2069.

17.Kryvoi Y, ‘Private or Public Adjudication? Procedure, Substance and Legitimacy’ (2021) 34 Leiden Journal of International Law 683.

18.Mandelbaum S, ‘The Legitimacy of Arbitral Reasoning: On Authority and Authorisation in International Investment Dispute Settlement’ (2020) 10 Czech and Central European Yearbook of Arbitration 113.

19.Petersen T, Saporta I and Seidel MD, ‘Offering a Job: Meritocracy and Social Networks’ (2000) 106(3) American Journal of Sociology 763.

20.Ten Cate IM, ‘Arbitrator Selection Default Rules’ (2025) 75 American University Law Review 461.

21.Ten Cate O and Chen HC, ‘The Ingredients of a Rich Entrustment Decision’ (2020) 42(12) Medical Teacher 1413.

22.Other Academic and Professional Sources

23.Hochstrasser D, ‘The Ins and Outs of Arbitrator Selection’ (SCCL Publications, Chapter 3).

24.Respondek A and Abels S, ‘Confidentiality in Arbitration Proceedings’ (The Singapore Law Gazette, September 2025).

25.Sahoo MS, ‘Party Autonomy: The Soul of Arbitration’ (Vidyashilp University 2025).

26.Schacherer S, ‘Independence and Impartiality of Arbitrators: A Rule of Law Analysis’ (2018).

27.Case Law

Aroma Franchise Company, Inc v Aroma Espresso Ba

Downloads

Published

2026-11-10