Defining “Neglect” in Early Soviet Turkestan: Terminology, Historiography and the Source Base for the Study of Institutions for Homeless Children and Adolescents, 1918–1924

Authors

  • Malika Kh. Murodova Researcher, National University of Uzbekistan named after Mirzo Ulugbek, Tashkent, Uzbekistan Author

Keywords:

homeless children; neglect; Turkestan ASSR; early Soviet social policy; historiography; orphanages; Central Asia

Abstract

The mass appearance of homeless and neglected children (besprizornye) was one of the most visible social consequences of war, revolution and famine in the former Russian Empire. Yet the vocabulary used to describe these children was unstable, and in Soviet Turkestan it was applied to a society whose family, charitable and legal institutions differed markedly from those of central Russia. This article examines how the categories “neglected child” (bezprizornost’, beznadzornost’) and “neglected adolescent” took shape in Russian and Soviet legal-pedagogical thought, how they were consolidated in Soviet legislation by 1926, and how they should be adapted for research on the Turkestan Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (Turkestan ASSR, 1918–1924). It then offers a four-part survey of the scholarship (Soviet-era practitioners, post-independence Uzbek historians, Russian and Kazakh historians, and Anglophone Sovietology) and reviews the archival and published sources on which the history of Turkestan’s educational and rehabilitative institutions can be written. The article argues that existing studies treat Turkestan mostly as a chronological or geographical fragment of broader Uzbek or all-Union narratives, and that the region’s specific institutional arrangements deserve to be studied in their own right.

References

1.all, A. (1994). And Now My Soul Is Hardened: Abandoned Children in Soviet Russia, 1918–1930. Berkeley: University of California Press.

2.Ball, A. (1993). State children: Soviet Russia’s bezprizornye and the new socialist generation. The Russian Review, 52(2), 228–247.

3.Buttino, M. (1990). Study of the economic crisis and depopulation in Turkestan, 1917–1920. Central Asian Survey, 9(4), 59–74.

4.Cameron, S. (2018). The Hungry Steppe: Famine, Violence, and the Making of Soviet Kazakhstan. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

5.Kamp, M. (2019). Hunger and potatoes: The 1933 famine in Uzbekistan and changing foodways. Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 20(2), 237–267.

6.Kufaev, V. I. (1924). Borba s pravonarusheniyami nesovershennoletnikh [The struggle against juvenile offences]. Moscow: Novaya Moskva. (In Russian)

7.Levitina, M. I. (1925). Besprizornye: Sotsiologiya, byt, praktika raboty [Homeless children: Sociology, everyday life, practice of work]. Moscow: Novaya Moskva. (In Russian)

8.Poznyshev, S. V. (1926). Detskaya besprizornost i mery borby s nei [Child homelessness and measures to combat it]. Moscow: Mosздравотдел. (In Russian)

9.Vasilevsky, L. M. (1924). Golgofa rebenka: Besprizornost i deti ulitsy [The Golgotha of the child: Homelessness and street children]. Leningrad–Moscow: Kniga. (In Russian)

10.Lyublinsky, P. I., & Kopelyanskaya, S. E. (1924). Okhrana detstva i borba s besprizornostyu [Protection of childhood and the struggle against homelessness]. Leningrad: Academia. (In Russian)

11.Savelyev, A. N., & Kostina, E. Yu. (n.d.). Problema detskoi besprizornosti v SSSR v 20–30 gody [The problem of child homelessness in the USSR in the 1920s–1930s]. Nauchnye issledovaniya i razrabotki molodykh uchenykh, 114–116. (In Russian)

12.Maslova, O. B. (2010). Likvidatsiya massovoi detskoi besprizornosti v Sovetskoi Rossii v 1920-e gody [The liquidation of mass child homelessness in Soviet Russia in the 1920s] (Candidate’s dissertation abstract). Pyatigorsk. (In Russian)

13.Slavko, A. A. (2011). Detskaya besprizornost i beznadzornost v Rossii kontsa 1920-kh – nachala 1950-kh godov [Child homelessness and neglect in Russia from the late 1920s to the early 1950s] (Doctoral dissertation abstract). Samara. (In Russian)

14.Lukashina, V. (2019, September 2). Deti Grazhdanskoi voiny: Besprizorniki 1920-kh godov [Children of the Civil War: The homeless children of the 1920s]. vatnikstan.ru. (In Russian)

15.Usmanov, F. A. (2022). Ўзбекистонда болалар қаровсизлиги масаласи (1917–1945 йиллар) [The problem of child neglect in Uzbekistan, 1917–1945] (PhD dissertation abstract). Termez. (In Uzbek) — cited above as [24].

16.Savelyev & Kostina, as in [11].

17.Saktaganova, Z. G., & Karsakova, G. B. (2017). Vliyanie goloda na rost chisla besprizornykh detei v Akmolinskoi gubernii v 1920-e gg. [The influence of famine on the growth of homeless children in Akmola province in the 1920s]. Vestnik KazNU, Seriya istoricheskaya, 3(86), 5–9. (In Russian)

18.Kaipbaeva, A. T., Kozybaeva, M. M., Mukhatova, O. Kh., Baizhumanova, Z. B., & Bekenova, A. A. (Comps.). (2025). Iz istorii borby s detskoi besprizornostyu v Kazakhstane i sopredelnykh stranakh v 1920–1930-e gg.: Sbornik arkhivnykh dokumentov i materialov [From the history of the struggle against child homelessness in Kazakhstan and neighbouring countries in the 1920s–1930s: Collection of archival documents]. Almaty: Balausa. (In Russian)

19.Usmanov, F. A. (2026). Child homelessness and neglect in the Uzbek SSR in the second half of the 1920s: Statistics, social portrait, and systemic crisis analysis. International Multidisciplinary Science Conference, 1(5), 171–176. Italy.

20.Usmanov, F. (2026). O‘zbekistonda bolalar qarovsizligini bartaraf etishda bolalar uylarining ahamiyati. Ўтмишга назар / Взгляд в прошлое / Look to the Past, 9(4/2), 53–59. (In Uzbek)

21.Khuzhanova, M. F. (2016). Istoriya detskikh domov v Uzbekistane: formirovanie, deyatelnost i problemy (1920–1930 gg.) [History of orphanages in Uzbekistan]. Molodoi uchenyi, 19(123), 284–288. (In Russian)

22.Stronski, P. (2010). Tashkent: Forging a Soviet City, 1930–1966. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.

23.Mamadaliev, Sh. (2023). Coverage of famine and starving children in the press (1917–1924). International Journal on Integrated Education, 6(12), 277–291.

24.Usmanov, F. A. (2022), as in item 15.

25.National Archive of Uzbekistan (NAU), f. R-25, op. 1, d. 682, l. 600.

26.Zenzinov, V. (1929). Besprizornye [The homeless]. Paris: Sovremennye zapiski. (In Russian)

27.Note on references: items 15a and 15b cited in the text refer to Rakhmatov, M. G. (2019), Famine in Turkestan and its consequences (1917–1924) (PhD dissertation, Tashkent; in Uzbek), and Rajabboev, N. A. (2020), Soviet food policy in Turkestan and its consequences (1917–1924) (PhD dissertation abstract, Tashkent; in Uzbek).

Downloads

Published

2026-11-08