THE PHENOMENON OF RELATIVE DEPRIVATION AND THE SOCIO-PHILOSOPHICAL INTERPRETATION OF INTER-CIVIC CONFLICT
Keywords:
relative deprivation, inter-civic conflict, reference group, fraternalistic deprivation, social justice, expectations, legitimacy of inequality, mobilisation, social comparison, Tocqueville paradox, social philosophy.Abstract
This article offers a socio-philosophical interpretation of relative deprivation and of its part in the formation of inter-civic conflict. The study proceeds from the observation that deprivation is not a quantity but a relation: it exists only as the discrepancy between what a person believes himself entitled to and what he receives, and therefore presupposes a standard of comparison that the facts of his condition do not supply. The philosophical contribution lies precisely there, since the reference group furnishing the standard is socially constituted rather than naturally given, and its constitution has been transformed by the universal visibility of other people’s circumstances. Four conditions are established under which deprivation acquires conflictual force, and the distinction between egoistic and fraternalistic deprivation is shown to determine whether distress is borne individually or becomes collective action. The polemic between T.R. Gurr and C. Tilly concerning grievance and mobilisation is subjected to critical examination.
References
1.Bekmurodov, M. Oʻzbek mentaliteti / M. Bekmurodov. – Toshkent: Yozuvchi, 1997. – 128 b.
2.Nazarov, Q. Qadriyatlar falsafasi: aksiologiya / Q. Nazarov. – Toshkent: OʻzFMJ, 2004. – 196 b.
3.Ergashbaev, S. Oʻzbekiston sharoitida uzluksiz taʼlim tizimi orqali yoshlarning maʼnaviy dunyoqarashini rivojlantirish / S. Ergashbaev // Объединяя студентов: международные исследования и сотрудничество между дисциплинами. – 2025. – Т. 1, № 1. – С. 314–316.
4.Gurr, T.R. Why Men Rebel / T.R. Gurr. – Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1970. – 421 p.
5.Runciman, W.G. Relative Deprivation and Social Justice / W.G. Runciman. – London: Routledge, 1966. – 338 p.
6.Ergashbayev, S. Uzluksiz taʼlim tashkil etish orqali yoshlarning maʼnaviy-falsafiy dunyoqarashini yuksaltirish / S. Ergashbayev // Bulletin of Contemporary Researches: Multidisciplinary. – 2025. – Vol. 1, No. 1. – P. 10–13.
7.Tilly, C. From Mobilization to Revolution / C. Tilly. – Reading: Addison-Wesley, 1978. – 349 p.
8.Tocqueville, A. de. The Old Regime and the Revolution. – New York: Harper, 1856. – 338 p.
9.Mirzaolimjon ogʻli, M.M. Yangi Oʻzbekistonning taʼlim siyosati va universitetlarning yangi modellari / M.M. Mirzaolimjon ogʻli, E. Shohbozbek // Pedagogik islohotlar va ularning yechimlari. – 2025. – T. 16, № 01. – B. 325–328.
10.Davies, J.C. Toward a Theory of Revolution / J.C. Davies // American Sociological Review. – 1962. – Vol. 27, No. 1. – P. 5–19