COMPARISON OF TAX REGIMES: VAT, COST STRUCTURE AND PRICE EFFECTS
Keywords:
turnover tax, corporate income tax, price, value added tax, tax regime, cost structure.Abstract
Comparing tax regimes solely on the basis of tax rates may mix differences in tax bases with the effects of value added tax (VAT). The purpose of the study is to compare a turnover tax regime with regimes involving VAT and corporate income tax under identical business conditions. An algebraic model, cash-flow consistency analysis, and sensitivity analysis were applied to a hypothetical resident legal entity using the general tax rates established by legislation. The model assumes that the sales volume remains unchanged, input VAT is fully creditable, expenses are deductible, and special tax incentives are excluded from the baseline calculation. Under initial revenue of UZS 800 million, purchases of UZS 500 million, and other expenses of UZS 100 million, the outcome under the turnover tax regime is UZS 108 million. Under the VAT regime, the outcome is UZS 97.14 million if the final price remains unchanged and UZS 170 million if VAT is fully passed through into the price. The break-even point is reached when the VAT pass-through coefficient reaches 14.90 percent, corresponding to a 1.79 percent increase in the buyer’s price. The share of VAT-inclusive purchases and transitional-period tax incentives alter this threshold. The results are not a universal tax recommendation but a comparative model whose assumptions must be empirically verified.
References
1.Massachusetts Institute of Technology. (2012). Tax analysis notes [14.471 Public Economics I kursi materiali]. MIT OpenCourseWare. https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/14-471-public-economics-i-fall-2012/resources/mit14_471f12_tax_analysis/
2.Mirsobitov, M. M. (2024). Tadbirkorlik subyektlarini qo‘llab quvvatlashda soliq ma’muriyatchiligining ahamiyati. Scientific Journal of Actuarial Finance and Accounting, 4(11), 530–536. https://doi.org/10.55439/AFA/vol4_iss11/838
3.Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2017). International VAT/GST guidelines. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264271401-en
4.O‘zbekiston Respublikasi. (2019). Soliq kodeksi (O‘RQ-599-son Qonun bilan yangi tahrirda tasdiqlangan; 2026-yil 7-sentabrda ochilgan tahrir). https://lex.uz/mact/4674902
5.Турғунмирзаев, А. (2025). НОВЫЕ ПРОЯВЛЕНИЯ КОНКУРЕНЦИИ В СФЕРЕ СТРАХОВЫХ УСЛУГ: ТЕОРИЯ И ПРАКТИКА. Экономическое развитие и анализ, 3(2), 368-376.
6.Турғунмирзаев, А. (2025). ЦИФРОВИЗАЦИЯ СТРАХОВОГО РЫНКА КАК ФАКТОР ПОВЫШЕНИЯ ЕГО КОНКУРЕНТОСПОСОБНОСТИ. Передовая экономика и педагогические технологии, 2(1), 289-297.
7.Тургунимирзаев, А. (2025). НАПРАВЛЕНИЯ СТРАТЕГИИ РАЗВИТИЯ СТРАХОВЫХ КОМПАНИЙ В ЦИФРОВОЙ ЭКОНОМИКЕ. Экономическое развитие и анализ, 3(1), 439-446.
8.ТУРҒУНМИРЗАЕВ, А. (2025). СУҒУРТА БОЗОРИНИ РАҚАМЛАШТИРИШ УНИНГ РАҚОБАТБАРДОШЛИГИНИ ОШИРИШНИНГ ОМИЛИ СИФАТИДА. ILGʻOR IQTISODIYOT VA PEDAGOGIK TEXNOLOGIYALAR Учредители: Shafi Science Center Ltd, 2(1), 289-297.
9.Турғунмирзаев, А., & Шамситдинов, М. (2023). Суғурта Компаниялари Рақобатбардошлигини Бошқаришда Рақамли Иқтисодиётнинг Ўрни. Nashrlar, 238-241.
10.Turgunimirzayev, A. Directions of the Development Strategy of Insurance Companies in the Digital Economy. Economic Development and Analysis, 3(1), 439-446.
11.Turgunmirzaev, A. New Appearances of Competition in the Insurance Services Sector: Theory and Practice. Economic Development and Analysis, 3(2), 368-376.
12.Turgʻunmirzayev, A. Digitalization of the Insurance Market as A Factor in Increasing Its Competitiveness. Advanced Economics and Pedagogical Technologies, 2(1), 289-297.
13.Turgunmirzaev, A. (2025). Developing Forms of Competition in The Insurance Field: Theory and Practical Aspects. Central Asian Journal of Innovations on Tourism Management and Finance, 6(3), 1083-1090.
14.Турғунмирзаев, А., & Шамситдинов, М. (2023). Суғурта Компаниялари Рақобатбардошлигини Бошқаришда Рақамли Иқтисодиётнинг Ўрни. Nashrlar, 238-241.