THE REPRESENTATION OF SOCIAL INEQUALITY IN KECHA VA KUNDUZ AND AN AMERICAN TRAGEDY: A COMPARATIVE LITERARY ANALYSIS

Authors

  • Ergasheva Bakhora Researcher of Samarkand State Institute of Foreign Languages Samarkand, Uzbekistan. Author

Keywords:

Social Inequality, Realism, Naturalism, Cho‘lpon, Theodore Dreiser, Comparative Literature, Class Stratification, Patriarchal Power.

Abstract

This scientific article explores the representation of social inequality through a comparative literary analysis of Abdulhamid Sulaymon o‘g‘li Cho‘lpon’s Uzbek realist novel Kecha va Kunduz (Night and Day, 1936) and Theodore Dreiser’s American naturalist masterpiece An American Tragedy (1925). Operating in radically distinct geographic, religious, and socio-political systems—early twentieth-century colonial Turkestan and Gilded Age capitalistic United States—both authors independently expose how rigid social hierarchies, economic divides, and institutional pressures crush individual agency. Utilizing qualitative comparative textual analysis grounded in historical-sociological criticism, this paper examines how Cho‘lpon highlights the convergence of patriarchal authority, local administrative corruption, and colonial submission, while Dreiser unmasks the toxic illusions of the "American Dream" and capitalist stratification. The findings indicate that despite variations in structural mechanisms (traditional-religious networks of patronage versus corporate-industrial hierarchies), both works depict social inequality as a deterministic force that precipitates psychological self-erasure and ultimate moral or physical destruction for the underprivileged.

References

1.Bekbergenovna, K. S. (2024). Human dignity in Hard Times and Night and Day: Personal freedom, pride, and social pressure. Literature and Culture Review, 5(2), 84–92.

2.Ergashev, A. (2015). Realism and social conflict in Cho'lpon's prose. Journal of Uzbek Literary Studies, 4(2), 45–58.

3.Ergasheva, B. (2025). Issues of social inequality in literature. Collection of Scientific Papers «SCIENTIA», (1), 164–167. Collection of scientific papers «SCIENTIA»

4.Sloane, D. E. E. (1992). Sister Carrie, Theodore Dreiser's sociological tragedy. Twayne Publishers, 45–58. Digital Commons @ New Haven - University of New Haven

5.Zhang, C., & Zhang, H. (2009). From American dreams to American tragedies — Theodore Dreiser’s ponderation on American society and ruination of morality. Asian Social Science, 5(6), 64–71.

6.Fort, C. (Trans.). (2020). Night and Day. Academic State Publishing House, 120–145.

7.Dreiser, T. (1925). An American Tragedy. Boni & Liveright, 210–245.

8.Saidov, U. (2018). Women's fate and social injustice in early twentieth-century Uzbek novels. Central Asian Literary Review, 6(1), 73–89. phoenixpublication.net

9.Temirov, N. (2023). Personal freedom in national and social contexts in the works of Cho‘lpon. Asian Journal of Scientific Research and Innovations, 1(1), 1023–1029.

10.Karimov, N. (1997). Cho'lpon: Life and creative legacy. Fan Publishing House, 88–104.

11.Khalid, A. (1998). The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform: Jadidism in Central Asia. University of California Press, 150–178.

12.Milanović, B. (2020). Literature and inequality: Economic realities in fictional worlds. Global Policy Journal, 11(3), 32–39.

Downloads

Published

2026-03-10