FROM ARMS CONTROL TO WATER GOVERNANCE: A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR APPLYING CONFIDENCE-BUILDING MEASURES TO TRANSBOUNDARY WATER DIPLOMACY
Keywords:
confidence-building measures; water diplomacy; transboundary water governance; institutional asymmetry; Amu Darya; Qosh Tepa CanalAbstract
This article develops a conceptual framework for transferring confidence-building measures (CBMs) from the field of arms control to transboundary water diplomacy. It brings together two bodies of scholarship that have so far developed in parallel: the Water Diplomacy Framework proposed by Islam and Susskind, and the classical CBM literature rooted in the Helsinki process and early United Nations disarmament research. The article argues that the two traditions share a structural kinship. Both treat conflict as a product of uncertainty, information deficits and mistrust rather than of physical scarcity alone. Both prefer procedural and incremental solutions to comprehensive settlements. On this basis, the article proposes a three-dimensional model of water-related CBMs, distinguishing informational, verificational and restraining measures, and assesses each dimension against three criteria: uncertainty reduction, escalation prevention and continuity. The model is then applied illustratively to the Amu Darya basin, where the exclusion of Afghanistan from the post-Soviet water governance architecture has produced a pronounced institutional asymmetry. The comparison reveals a functioning but incomplete CBM regime among the five post-Soviet riparian states, and an effectively pre-institutional situation in relations with Afghanistan. The article concludes that CBMs offer a workable intermediate mechanism between purely technical water management and formal treaty-making in basins where legal instruments are politically unavailable. The framework is offered as an analytical tool that can be extended to other asymmetric basins, including the Nile and the Mekong.
References
1.Al Jazeera. (2025, July 9). Can India stop Pakistan’s river water — and will it spark a new war? https://www.aljazeera.com
2.Blue Peace Initiative. (n.d.). Water diplomacy and mediation. https://www.thebluepeaceinitiative.org/water-diplomacy.html
3.Capie, D., & Evans, P. (2007). Confidence- and security-building measures. In The Asia-Pacific security lexicon (2nd ed., pp. 89–92). ISEAS–Yusof Ishak Institute.
4.Center for Strategic and International Studies. (2025). Can India cut off Pakistan's Indus River lifeline? Critical Questions. https://www.csis.org
5.Clingendael Institute. (2025). Indus Waters Treaty 2025: A pause of cooperation, not an end. Clingendael Institute.
6.Crosslin, E. L. (2025). Monitoring the Qosh Tepa Canal project: A geospatial timeline of Taliban water diversion.
7.Islam, S., & Susskind, L. E. (2012). Water diplomacy: A negotiated approach to managing complex water networks.
8.Islam, S., & Susskind, L. E. (2015). Water diplomacy: A negotiated approach to manage complex water problems. Journal of Contemporary Water Research & Education, 155(1), 1–10.
9.Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe. (2011). Vienna Document 2011 on confidence- and security-building measures. OSCE.
10.Sehring, J., Schmeier, S., ter Horst, R., Offutt, A., & Sharipova, B. (2022). Diving into water diplomacy: Exploring the emergence of a concept. Diplomatica, 4(2), 200–221.
11.Stockholm International Water Institute. Water diplomacy. Water Knowledge Hub. https://waterknowledgehub.org/learn/iwrm-tools/water-diplomacy
12.The Times of Central Asia. (2026). Afghanistan advances Qosh Tepa Canal while urging regional water cooperation. https://timesca.com
13.United Nations Economic Commission for Europe. (2023). Updated strategies for monitoring and assessment of transboundary rivers, lakes and groundwaters. United Nations.
14.United Nations Economic Commission for Europe. (2024). Good practices and lessons learned in data-sharing in transboundary basins. United Nations.
15.United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research. (1985). Confidence-building measures and international security: The political and military aspects. UNIDIR.