CONFIDENTIALITY IN ARB-MED-ARB: THE USE OF MEDIATION INFORMATION IN RESUMED ARBITRATION

Authors

  • Isaeva Sevinch Oybek qizi Master's student, International Arbitration and Dispute Resolution, University of World Economy and Diplomacy Author

Keywords:

Keywords: Arb-Med-Arb, arbitration, mediation, confidentiality, mediation information, admissibility of evidence, arbitrator, mediator, impartiality, Uzbekistan.

Abstract

Arb-Med-Arb has emerged as a hybrid dispute resolution mechanism combining the adjudicative function of arbitration with the consensual and flexible nature of mediation. Under this procedure, a dispute is first submitted to arbitration, subsequently referred to mediation, and, if no settlement is reached, returned to arbitration. The mechanism is designed to enable parties to explore settlement without losing access to a binding arbitral determination. However, the sequential interaction between arbitration and mediation raises a distinct procedural question: what should happen to information disclosed during mediation when arbitration resumes?

The issue is particularly significant because mediation depends upon confidentiality and candid communication. Parties may disclose settlement offers, concessions, assessments of their legal position and other information that would not otherwise be disclosed in arbitration. If mediation fails, allowing such information to influence the subsequent arbitral proceedings may undermine both the confidentiality of mediation and the parties’ willingness to participate openly. The problem becomes even more complex where the same individual performs the functions of mediator and arbitrator.

This paper examines the limits of using mediation-related information in resumed arbitration, analyses relevant international standards and considers the adequacy of the existing legal framework of Uzbekistan. It argues that the development of Arb-Med-Arb requires a functional separation between information generated exclusively for mediation and evidence that independently exists outside the mediation process. The paper proposes several directions for improving Uzbek legislation, including clearer rules on evidentiary admissibility, confidentiality, the burden of proof and the consequences of using protected mediation information in subsequent arbitration.

Downloads

Published

2026-09-27