DIGITAL SELF-DETERMINATION AS A FUNDAMENTAL CONSTITUTIONAL PRINCIPLE FOR DATA RIGHTS IN THE AGE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

Authors

  • Abhijith A.S National Forensic Sciences University, India Tashkent State University of Law, Uzbekistan Author
  • Islombek Abdikhakimov Under the Supervision of Dr. Author

Keywords:

Keywords: Digital Self-Determination, Artificial Intelligence Governance, Informational Privacy, Data Protection, Digital Personal Data Protection Act (DPDP)

Abstract

The rapid evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has radically altered the relationship between human beings and personal data. Rather than merely storing or retrieving historical records, modern machine learning systems actively infer, predict, classify and evaluate human behaviour, transforming passive datasets into instruments of structural governance. This study evaluates the concept of digital self-determination as a fundamental constitutional principle necessary to preserve human agency, dignity and autonomy against expanding algorithmic power. Through a comparative analysis of three distinct legal landscapes which includes Germany's mature constitutional doctrine of informational self-determination, India's evolving data privacy framework following the landmark Puttaswamy judgment and the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act of 2023 and Uzbekistan's emerging statutory and ethical AI governance regimes highlights critical gaps between constitutional aspirations and legislative realities. It argues that traditional notice and consent mechanisms are structurally inadequate in complex algorithmic environments. Instead, a higher order constitutional principle of digital self-determination must be institutionalized globally to address both individual and collective algorithmic harms, ensuring that the human person remains the normative centre of digital governance.

References

1.Access Partnership. (2023). The key policy frameworks governing AI in India. Access Partnership.

2.Bhandari, V., et al. (2017). An analysis of Puttaswamy: The Supreme Court's privacy verdict and its implications. IndraStra Global. SSRN Preprint.

3.Carnegie Endowment. (2024, November 20). India’s advance on AI regulation. Carnegie.

4.Cerberus Legal. (2025, February 12). Uzbekistan moves to regulate Artificial Intelligence (AI) [Client Alert].

5.Corteza Project. (2025, June 9). AI is used to dismantle the human right to privacy. Corteza Project Blog.

6.DRZE – German Reference Centre for Ethics in the Life Sciences. (2023). Informational self-determination [DRZE Research Module].

7.European Court of Human Rights, & Pollicino, O. (2021). Digital private powers exercising public functions – Rule of law challenges [Presentation]. ECHR.

8.European Journal of Law and Technology. (2024). AI governance in India – Law, policy and political economy. European Journal of Law and Technology, 15(2).

9.European Scientific Journal. (2025). AI and cyber-enabled threats to democracy through digital platforms. European Scientific Journal.

10.Government of India. (2025, November 19). Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023 – Key features. Press Information Bureau.

11.Government of India, Office of Principal Scientific Adviser. (2026, January 22). AI governance through a techno-legal framework [White Paper].

12.Hornung, G., & Schnabel, C. (2009). Data protection in Germany I: The population census decision and the right to informational self-determination. Computer Law & Security Review.

13.Just Access. (2025, January 23). Digital self-determination – Learning to preserve individual dignity and autonomy in an online world. Just-Access Blog.

14.Lakra, R., & Jha, N. (2025). Reclaiming informational self-determination in the DPDPA 2023: A constitutional case for purpose limitation and data minimization. DigiCon Blog / SSRN Working Paper.

15.Lakra, R., & Jha, N. (2026). Re-evaluating publicly available data under the DPDP Act 2023: A constitutional perspective [Draft research paper]. LinkedIn.

16.Law and Tech.ie. (2024, April 21). DPDPA 2023 vs. GDPR: A comparative analysis of India’s and EU’s data privacy laws. https://lawandtech

17.Limam Blog. (2024, May 21). A quest for the legality of predictive data analytics in law enforcement: Landmark judgment on automated data analysis by the German Federal Constitutional Court. https://limablog

18.Montreal AI Ethics Institute. (2022, February 20). The impact of the GDPR on artificial intelligence. https://montrealethics

19.Nexos AI. (2025, November 16). GDPR for AI: Is your data protected when using AI? [Blog post]. https://nexos

20.Office of the United Nations. (2024, July 24). Risk management profile for AI and human rights. US Dept of State. https://2021-2025.state

21.Operationalizing Digital Self-Determination Collective. (2023). Operationalizing digital self-determination. Data & Policy. Cambridge University Press. https://arxiv

22.Policy Review. (2012). Consent under pressure and the right to informational self-determination. Internet Policy Review, 1(2). https://policyreview

23.Pulatov, K. (2026, January 19). Uzbekistan’s Parliament approves Personal Data Law amendments [LinkedIn post]. LinkedIn. https://linkedin

24.Rakhmatov, R. (2025, April 26). AI policy in Uzbekistan: Should we follow global models or our own path? [LinkedIn article]. LinkedIn. https://linkedin

25.Retskraft, & Şerbanescu, B. (2024). Why does artificial intelligence challenge democracy? Retskraft Journal, 5(1). https://retskraft

26.RSIS International. (2024). The impact of artificial intelligence on privacy laws. International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science (IJRISS). https://rsisinternational

27.Sage Journals. (2025). India’s AI regulation at the crossroads: A comprehensive assessment. Indian Journal of Law and Technology. https://journals.sagepub

28.Sanjar. (2025). Regulating artificial intelligence in Uzbekistan. ICAS Conference Proceedings. Inlibrary.uz. https://inlibrary

29.State Department of the United States. (2024, July 24). Risk management profile for AI and human rights. https://2021-2025.state

30.Swiss Data Alliance. (2013). Definition: Digital self-determination (Glossary entry). https://swissdataalliance

31.TandF Cogent Social Sciences. (2025). Reflections on the data protection compliance of AI systems. Cogent Social Sciences. https://tandfonline

32.United Nations / EJIL:Talk!. (2025, November 11). A human right to informational self-determination: What it is and why it matters for digital human rights. https://ejiltalk

33.Uzbekistan. (2026). Law ‘On Personal Data’ (as amended by Law No. 1125 and subsequent amendments, including 2026 clarification of storage and localisation rules). https://blackswan

34.Uzbekistan AI Ethical Rules. (c. 2023–2024). Ethical rules for the use of artificial intelligence (Government resolution). https://cerberus

35.Vakhidov Law. (2025). Legislative updates in the field of artificial intelligence and personal data regulation in Uzbekistan (Firm Newsletter). https://vakhidovlaw

36.VivaTech. (2026, March 18). The impact of AI on democracy: Risks and opportunities. https://vivatech

37.World State of AI Initiative / IITM. (2025). Making AI self-regulation work (Policy paper). https://wsai.iitm.ac

38.Yale Journal of Law and Technology. (c. 2024–2025). Artificial intelligence: Risks to privacy and democracy. Yale Journal of Law and Technology (YJoLT). https://yjolt

Downloads

Published

2026-07-13